The Vermont Revivals of 1809: A Religious Awakening in Concord, Guildhall, and Norwich

The year 1809 witnessed a surge of religious fervour across the United States, an exciting moment in the Second Great Awakening. While the fires of revival burned brightly in prominent centres like Cane Ridge, Kentucky, a quieter yet significant awakening stirred in the towns of Concord, Guildhall, and Norwich, Vermont.

This article looks into the history of these revivals, exploring their origins, key figures, impact on local communities, and their connection to the broader religious landscape of early 19th-century America. This was not an isolated phenomenon; revivals were occurring throughout New England and in other parts of the country, such as Long Island and Demerara ¹.

Religious Landscape of Vermont Before 1809

Before delving into the specifics of the 1809 revivals, it’s crucial to understand the social and religious context in which they occurred. Vermont in the early 19th century was a region marked by both political and economic complexities. Tensions lingered from disputes with New York over land titles, and the British maintained a presence, influencing trade routes and raising concerns about potential conflict ². These external pressures likely contributed to a sense of uncertainty and a desire for stability within the communities.

Amidst this backdrop, Vermont’s religious landscape was characterized by a distinctive blend of freedom and established practices. Unlike many other states, Vermont did not have a single, state-mandated denomination ². Instead, the state constitution, adopted in 1777, allowed each town to determine its preferred religious affiliation by majority vote ³. This resulted in a diverse yet predominantly Protestant population, with Congregationalism being the most prevalent denomination among the early settlers ⁴.

This emphasis on local autonomy in religious matters was further reflected in Vermont’s unique approach to religious governance. Clergy were often “hired” by a vote of citizens at town meetings, and taxes to support religious activities were authorized by the legislature ³.

This system, where civic participation played a direct role in religious affairs, reflected a close intertwining of religious and civic life in early Vermont ³. This practice was legally formalized in 1797 with an act that empowered towns to associate for religious purposes, levy taxes, build meeting houses, and hire religious teachers ⁵.

However, this period also saw the rise of challenges to traditional religious authority. The rise of Deism and the influence of Enlightenment ideas led to increased scepticism and a decline in religious practices in some quarters ⁶. The 1809 revivals emerged amidst this complex religious landscape, representing a resurgence of traditional faith and a response to the growing secularization of American society ⁶.

The 1809 Revivals: A Town-by-Town Account

Concord

The revival in Concord appears to have commenced towards the end of 1809 within the Congregationalist community ⁷. A letter dated January 11, 1810, published in The Christian’s Magazine, provides valuable insights into the revival’s impact:

• On Sunday, January 7th, 1810, nearly 40 individuals joined the Congregationalist Church, a significant increase considering the town’s population of 677 in 1810 ⁷. This suggests that the revival had a considerable impact, with approximately 6% of the town’s population joining the church.
• The church held three services on Sundays and conducted meetings in different parts of the town up to four evenings a week, indicating an intensified focus on religious activities ⁷.

The pastor of the Concord church at this time was Rev. Samuel Goddard, who later moved to Norwich and continued to witness and participate in revivals there ⁷.

Guildhall

The revival in Concord spread to the nearby town of Guildhall, located approximately 25 miles away ⁷. Described as an “astonishing revival,” the movement in Guildhall saw a remarkable surge in church membership:

• Forty-two new members joined the church, with 13 more in the process of joining, representing about 8% of the town’s population of 544 in 1810 ⁷.

 The revival’s impact extended beyond the church walls, with the entire town reportedly experiencing “deep concern” for their spiritual well-being ⁷.

 Notably, two judges and two attorneys from Guildhall joined the church, demonstrating the revival’s reach across different segments of society ⁷.

Norwich

While specific details about the 1809 revival in Norwich are limited, the town experienced a series of revivals during this era, suggesting a sustained religious fervour that may have been influenced by the events of 1809 and the broader Second Great Awakening. Rev. Samuel Goddard, who had previously served as pastor in Concord, documented five revivals of varying intensity during his 17-year ministry in Norwich, starting in 1822 ⁷. These revivals resulted in a significant number of converts:

• In 1821 and 1822, 88 people joined the church.
• In 1826, 1831, and 1835, approximately 40 people were added to the church during each revival.
• In the winter of 1836-37, a revival among Sabbath School children led to 16 new members.

To illustrate the potential scale of these revivals, it’s worth noting that the nearby town of Middlebury experienced a similar surge in religious enthusiasm around the same time, with over 280 converts joining the church ⁸. This suggests that the revivals in Norwich may have had a comparable impact on the local community.

Origins and Manifestations of the Revivals

Possible Triggers

While the specific events that sparked the 1809 revivals in these Vermont towns remain somewhat unclear, the account of the Middlebury revival, which occurred around the same time, provides a possible parallel ⁸. In Middlebury, the revival was ignited by a gathering of young people who experienced a collective sense of conviction and a renewed commitment to religious life. This suggests that the revivals may have been driven by a combination of factors, including:

Role of Young People

Young people played a significant role in the Second Great Awakening, and their enthusiasm and zeal may have been instrumental in spreading the revivals in Vermont ⁹. The Middlebury example highlights how young people could initiate and drive religious awakenings within their communities.

Religious Practices

The act of public confession and sharing of personal religious experiences appears to have been a catalyst for conviction and conversion in Middlebury, and similar practices may have contributed to the revivals in Concord and Guildhall ¹⁰. Increased church services, meetings, and prayer gatherings likely created an environment conducive to spiritual reflection and renewal ⁷.

Unfortunately, historical accounts do not provide details about specific prayers offered during the revivals or the precise manifestations of the Holy Spirit ⁸. However, accounts from other revivals during the Second Great Awakening suggest that emotional preaching, fervent prayer, and a sense of collective religious experience were common features ¹¹.

Personal Testimonies

While specific personal testimonies from the 1809 Vermont revivals are scarce, the broader context of the Second Great Awakening provides insights into the types of experiences that individuals may have had. During this period, revivals were often characterized by intense emotional experiences, conversions, and a renewed sense of religious devotion. People from various walks of life, including students, community leaders, and families, were drawn into the movement.

One account from Middlebury describes how a group of young people, initially gathered for social purposes, experienced a sudden wave of conviction and a desire for spiritual renewal ⁸. This sense of collective awakening spread throughout the community, leading to increased church attendance and a surge in conversions.

In Concord, the revival led to a significant increase in church membership, with nearly 40 people joining the Congregationalist Church in a single day ⁷. This suggests that individuals were deeply affected by the revival’s message and felt compelled to publicly declare their faith.

While the specific details of individual experiences may be lost to history, the overall impact of the revivals on personal faith and religious commitment is evident in the accounts of increased church membership and the spread of religious fervour throughout the communities.

The Place of Prayer

The research material provides limited information about the specific locations where prayer gatherings and religious services were held during the 1809 revivals. However, it’s likely that churches played a central role in facilitating these activities. In Concord, the Congregationalist Church held three services on Sundays and conducted meetings in different parts of the town, suggesting that both the church building and private homes may have served as spaces for prayer and religious gatherings ⁷.

In Guildhall, the revival’s impact extended beyond the church walls, with the entire town reportedly experiencing “deep concern” for their spiritual well-being ⁷. This suggests that prayer and religious discussions may have taken place in various settings, including homes, community gatherings, and possibly even public spaces.

Drawing from accounts of other revivals during the Second Great Awakening, it’s plausible that outdoor meetings and camp meetings may have also been organized in some areas. These gatherings often involved large crowds, emotional preaching, and extended periods of prayer and religious exhortation.

Overall, while the specific places of prayer during the 1809 revivals remain somewhat obscure, it’s clear that both established religious spaces and informal gatherings played a role in fostering the religious enthusiasm that swept through these Vermont communities.

Key Figures and Churches Involved

While no nationally prominent leaders are specifically mentioned in connection with the 1809 revivals in Concord and Guildhall, Rev. Samuel Goddard’s role as pastor in Concord during the revival and his subsequent documentation of revivals in Norwich suggest his involvement in the movement ⁷. Additionally, the account of the Guildhall revival mentions the participation of two judges and two attorneys, indicating that local community leaders played a role in supporting and spreading the religious fervor ⁷.

The revivals primarily involved Congregationalist churches in Concord and Guildhall ⁷. However, the broader religious landscape of Vermont at the time included Baptists, Episcopalians, Methodists, and Quakers, and it’s possible that these denominations were also influenced by the revivalist spirit and participated in the movement ¹².

Impact and Legacy

The 1809 revivals had a significant impact on the religious landscape of Concord, Guildhall, and potentially Norwich. The immediate results included a substantial increase in church membership, heightened religious activity, and a renewed focus on spiritual matters within the communities ⁸. The revivals likely contributed to the strengthening of religious institutions and a reaffirmation of traditional faith in the face of growing secular influences.

While the long-term effects are harder to quantify, the revivals likely played a role in shaping the religious and social fabric of these towns in the years that followed. The emphasis on personal piety, community engagement, and religious commitment undoubtedly influenced social reform movements and contributed to the overall religious climate of Vermont during the 19th century.

The 1809 Revivals and the Second Great Awakening

The 1809 revivals in Vermont were certainly part of the larger Second Great Awakening that swept across the United States during this period ⁸. This nationwide religious movement was characterized by emotional preaching, fervent prayer, camp meetings, and a renewed emphasis on personal religious experience ¹³. The revivals in Concord, Guildhall, and Norwich shared these characteristics, reflecting the broader trends of the Second Great Awakening.

The Second Great Awakening had a profound impact on American society, contributing to the rise of new religious denominations, social reform movements, and a surge in religious participation ¹⁴. The Vermont revivals, though less well-known than those in other regions, played a significant role in this larger religious and social transformation.

Conclusion: Key Takeaways and Lessons Learned

The 1809 revivals in Concord, Guildhall, and Norwich offer valuable insights into the religious landscape of early 19th-century Vermont and the broader Second Great Awakening. These revivals demonstrate the power of personal testimony, youthful piety, and community engagement in fostering religious enthusiasm and strengthening religious institutions.

The unique characteristics of Vermont’s religious landscape, with its emphasis on local autonomy and civic participation in religious governance, likely played a role in shaping the nature of these revivals. The revivals also highlight the dynamic interplay between established religious practices and the evolving social and intellectual currents of the time, as traditional faith responded to the challenges of Deism and Enlightenment ideas.

While the specific details of these revivals remain somewhat obscure, their impact on local communities and their connection to the larger Christian awakening are undeniable. The 1809 revivals serve as a reminder of the enduring power of religious revivals and the role of faith in shaping American history and society.

Several key takeaways emerge from this examination of the 1809 revivals:

• Revivals as catalysts for spiritual and social change: The revivals demonstrate how periods of intense religious fervour can lead to increased Christian commitment, strengthen religious institutions, and potentially influence social reform movements. 

• The role of young people in religious awakenings: The accounts of the revivals highlight the significant role that young people played in initiating and spreading the Gospel and commitment to Christ, particularly during the Second Great Awakening. 

• The importance of personal testimony and community engagement: The revivals underscore the power of personal religious experiences and public declarations of faith to draw others into the experience of conversion and commitment. 

• The dynamic interplay between religion and society: The revivals illustrate how revived churches can both reflect and respond to broader social and intellectual trends, shaping the religious landscape and influencing the course of history.

The 1809 revivals in Vermont, though less widely known than some of their counterparts in other regions, offer a valuable case study for understanding the dynamics of religious awakenings and their impact on individuals, communities, and the broader society.

Works cited

1. Restoration Movement – Wikipedia, accessed on December 15, 2024, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Restoration_Movement
2. vermonthistory.org, accessed on December 15, 2024, https://vermonthistory.org/journal/misc/CivilReligion.pdf
3. vermonthistory.org, accessed on December 15, 2024, https://vermonthistory.org/journal/misc/FormationOfTownChurches.pdf
4. Congregationalism in the United States – Wikipedia, accessed on December 15, 2024, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congregationalism_in_the_United_States
5. A General History of the Baptist Denomination, David Benedict | The Reformed Reader, accessed on December 15, 2024, https://www.reformedreader.org/history/benedict/baptistdenomination/vermont.htm
6. Vermont History, accessed on December 15, 2024, https://vermonthistory.org/journal/misc/HartlandChurches.pdf
7. 1809 Revivals in Concord, Guildhall, & Norwich, Vermont – BEAUTIFUL FEET, accessed on December 15, 2024, https://romans1015.com/concord/
8. 1809 Middlebury, Vermont Revival – BEAUTIFUL FEETBEAUTIFUL FEET, accessed on December 15, 2024, https://romans1015.com/middlebury/
9. The Role of Youth in the Second Great Awakening – BYU ScholarsArchive, accessed on December 15, 2024, https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4801&context=etd
10. ESDA | Preston, Rachel Harris Oaks (1809-1868) – Adventist Encyclopedia, accessed on December 15, 2024, https://encyclopedia.adventist.org/article?id=AIQ1
11. Religious Revivals and Revivalism in 1830s New England | Teach US History, accessed on December 15, 2024, https://www.teachushistory.org/second-great-awakening-age-reform/articles/religious-revivals-revivalism-1830s-new-england
12. Vermont Church History – FamilySearch, accessed on December 15, 2024, https://www.familysearch.org/en/wiki/Vermont_Church_History
13. Second Great Awakening – Wikipedia, accessed on December 15, 2024, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Great_Awakening
14. The Second Great Awakening – Mark Stoll, accessed on December 15, 2024, https://www.markstoll.net/HIST2300/2020_Spring/10_Second_Great_Awakening.htm